Costello’s Cookies

Welcome to
Costello's Cookies

Baked with Tradition,
Served with Pride

Indulge in the art of fine Italian shortbread cookie making with Costello’s Cookies, where every crumb tells a story of uncompromised quality and traditional baking. Here, we blend time-honored techniques with the purest ingredients to create not just cookies, but culinary masterpieces. Discover the perfect harmony of taste and texture with our seasonal selections and custom creations, all crafted to make life a little sweeter.

The Artisan's Touch in Every Batch

Each Costello’s Italian shortbread cookie is a canvas, where the precision of artisanal baking meets the fresh vibrancy of our select ingredients. Our bakers, true modern-day artisans, infuse their passion and expertise into every batch, crafting cookies that are as delightful to behold as they are to devour. Celebrating the joy of handmade quality, we invite you to taste the difference that attention to detail and a personal touch can make in every bite—be it a seasonal favorite or a custom-designed treat for your special event.

What Makes Us Different

Unique Heritage

We distinguish ourselves with details. Every Italian shortbread cookie combines past and present, from our heirloom recipes to our modern designs. We promote community relationships to enhance our creations.

Fresh Craftsmanship

Our baking celebrates variety, with flavors and designs for all tastes and occasions. We bake our cookies fresh to order, giving them a personal touch that mass-produced brands can't match.

Tailored Service

Our Cookie Concierge helps you choose and customize cookies to make your experience as perfect as the treats. Our personalized service begins with the first click and ends with the last crumb.

Sensory Perfection

Delight in the symphony of aromas and the exquisite flavors that define Costello’s Cookies. Each Italian shortbread cookie is a masterpiece, with its artful design matched only by its irresistible taste and texture.

What Our Clients Say

5/5
“Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, te has solet postea. Voluptua quaestio dissentias has ex, no eum aliquid tibique petentium, agam mucius liberavisse eos idt.”
Francis Mathis
5/5
“Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, te has solet postea. Voluptua quaestio dissentias has ex, no eum aliquid tibique petentium, agam mucius liberavisse eos idt.”
Francis Mathis
5/5
“Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, te has solet postea. Voluptua quaestio dissentias has ex, no eum aliquid tibique petentium, agam mucius liberavisse eos idt.”
Francis Mathis

Tailored Treats for Every Occasion

At Costello’s Cookies, we understand that every event is unique and every occasion deserves a special touch. Our tailored treats are designed to capture the essence of your celebration, handcrafted to suit your specific desires. From corporate events that reflect your brand’s ethos to personal milestones that tell your story, our bespoke Italian shortbread cookies are as individual as your memories. Connect with us to bring your custom confectionery dreams to life, crafted with care for gatherings large and small.

Get a Free Quote